All articles
Technical SEO · · 7 min read

What a Free Website Audit Checks on Shopify

A free audit reads your store from the outside against a fixed checklist. Here is what that covers, how Shopify changes the results, and what it cannot see.

Magnifying glass on a printed blueprint.
On this page

A free website audit reads your store from the outside and checks it against a fixed list of rules: whether search engines can crawl and index your pages, whether titles and headings are in place, how fast the pages load, whether structured data exists, and how the store looks to search and AI tools. It cannot see inside your accounts, and generic tools often flag normal Shopify behavior as errors, so the results need reading with Shopify in mind.

What SEO Karbon's free audit checks

SEO Karbon's free Shopify SEO audit runs 71 checks across 10 areas: crawl and indexation, speed, structured data, on-page content, conversion and trust, AI search visibility and off-site authority, among others. It needs no login, Search Console or app install, because everything it measures can be seen from the public site. Findings show the evidence they were measured from and are ranked by revenue at risk. It also looks for Shopify-specific faults that generic scanners miss, such as /collections/all duplicates and variant and filter URLs, and it reads domain rating and referring domains live from Ahrefs.

The rest of this guide explains each kind of check so you can read any audit's results.

Crawlability and indexability

An audit checks your robots.txt and XML sitemap, confirms the sitemap lists URLs that return a 200 status, and looks for pages blocked by robots.txt or marked noindex.

On Shopify, the default robots.txt is set by the platform and blocks the cart, checkout, internal search and several sort and filter URLs. You can customize it with a robots.txt.liquid template. Audit tools often report that these paths are blocked. That is expected, because those pages should not be indexed.

Canonical tags and URL structure

The tool checks that each page has a canonical tag, either pointing to itself or to a master version. Shopify can serve a product at /products/blue-shirt and at /collections/mens/products/blue-shirt, and it canonicalizes the collection path to the clean address. A good audit confirms that, and flags themes that still link through the longer path. It also looks for very long URLs, many parameters and uppercase characters.

Audits crawl your internal links for 404s and trace redirect chains, where one address redirects to another that redirects again. Shopify's redirect tool handles simple redirects well, but deleted products and changed handles create broken links inside product descriptions and blog posts that a crawler is good at finding.

Titles, descriptions and headings

The audit checks that titles and meta descriptions exist, whether they are duplicated across pages, and whether they fit typical length limits. In Shopify, missing ones usually mean a gap in product or collection data. Some tools flag a title as too long only because the theme appends the store name, which is a choice to make page by page.

It also checks headings: one H1, then H2 and H3 in order. On Shopify the product or collection title is normally the H1, so a missing H1 on the homepage often means a logo image with no text alternative.

Disassembled machine components organized neatly on a workbench.
Separating the components helps identify which parts need attention.

Images and alt text

The scan looks at <img> tags for an alt attribute and may flag very large files. Missing alt text is a real gap you can fix in the admin. See the image alt text guide.

Speed and Core Web Vitals

Most audits include speed measurements, often from Google's Lighthouse or PageSpeed data: Largest Contentful Paint, Interaction to Next Paint and Cumulative Layout Shift. On Shopify you cannot change server caching, so the fixes are in your theme, apps and media. Slow LCP usually means a large or lazy-loaded hero or product image. High CLS usually comes from announcement bars, review stars or carousels that load late. See the Core Web Vitals guide.

Structured data

A good audit looks at whether product pages carry Product markup and what is missing, such as identifiers. See the product schema guide.

AI search visibility and off-site authority

A modern audit also reports how AI assistants describe the store and how strong its backlink profile is. The first needs repeated sampling because answers vary, and the second needs data from a link index.

What automated tools cannot check

  • Whether you target the right keywords. A tool can see that a keyword is in a title tag, not whether it is the right keyword, or whether your page satisfies the intent better than a competitor's.
  • Anything behind a login. Search Console, analytics and ad data need access, which is what a paid audit adds. See free versus paid audits.
  • Content quality and persuasion. Whether descriptions convert needs a human reader.
  • JavaScript-rendered content in some tools. Many free tools read only the initial HTML, so a store that injects content with scripts or runs headless can look empty to them.

How to read the results

Separate generic warnings from real Shopify problems. Ignore warnings about server settings you cannot change. Prioritize broken internal links, missing alt text on product images, layout shifts from your theme or apps, and canonical problems on product and collection pages. How to read an SEO audit report goes through this in detail, and how to do an SEO audit on Shopify shows how to run the checks by hand.

To see all of this on your own store, run the free audit. For complex structural issues, such as restructuring a tag and filter system or resolving conflicts between several SEO apps, Digital Karbon can help.

Next step

See how your own store scores

The free audit checks your store against the issues in this article — indexation, duplicate collections, page speed and everything else that holds a Shopify store back — and shows you what to fix first.